Skip to content
Bench WatchClosing the gap between the courtroom and everyday life.

Need help now? Free, confidential help lines, 24/7. Get help

Supreme CourtWatching

Christa Pike execution case

Pike v. Tennessee

Colleen Slemmer's mother, speaking to WBIR after the failed execution. (WBIR Channel 10 · Embedded from the owner's channel)

Watch the court record with us.

Subscribe on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

Bench Watch Brief · Where this case stands

Christa Gail Pike, sentenced to death in Tennessee for a 1995 murder, survived an attempted lethal injection on Sept. 30, 2026, hours after the U.S. Supreme Court lifted a stay over three justices' dissent. She is back in prison, and in an Oct. 30 statement she said she has been in pain since that night. The governor ordered an outside review; no new execution date has been set.

The question at issue

Pike's petition asked the Supreme Court whether severe psychological suffering can support an Eighth Amendment challenge to a method of execution, citing her post-traumatic stress disorder, and whether a Tennessee Supreme Court rule unconstitutionally limits method-of-execution challenges. Tennessee argued the Court lacked jurisdiction and that both claims failed.

Outcome

The Supreme Court denied review and a stay on Sept. 29, 2026, without explanation. On Sept. 30 it vacated a Sixth Circuit stay of execution; Justice Sotomayor, joined by Justices Kagan and Jackson, dissented. The lethal injection carried out that day did not cause Pike's death.

The Tennessee State Capitol in Nashville
The Tennessee State Capitol in Nashville. (Photo: Kaldari / Wikimedia Commons, public domain)

Why we're following it

Media witnesses were admitted at 6:26 p.m. The curtain closed for the last time at 8:05 p.m., and witnesses were told to leave at 8:53 p.m. while Pike was still breathing (Nashville Banner).

Her lawyers filed an emergency motion that night to halt the procedure. In a statement that night, they said the concerns Pike had raised, including difficult vein access and degraded pentobarbital, “proved to be true” (CBS News). The Department of Correction says it followed its protocol (WDBJ).

Bench Watch BreakdownMethod-of-execution challengeShow or hide the explanation
What it means
The Constitution bans cruel and unusual punishment. A person facing death can argue that the way the state plans to do it would cause too much pain. Courts call this a method-of-execution claim.
In this case
Pike filed this kind of claim in June 2026. A court officer held a three-day hearing on it in August. The state's attempt on Sept. 30 did not cause her death.
Why it matters
The Supreme Court has made these claims hard to win. A person usually has to point to another way that would cause less pain.

The Eighth Amendment

Gov. Bill Lee ordered a “comprehensive, third-party review” (WDBJ) and called off the execution of Gary Wayne Sutton, which had been set for Dec. 3 (WSMV via Hawaii News Now). On Oct. 3, his office announced that former U.S. Attorney Ed Stanton would lead the review, and Lee said Correction Commissioner Frank Strada would step down that month (AP via WBTV). On Oct. 30, Lee named Christopher Hansen interim commissioner (Governor's office).

On Oct. 7, Davidson County Chancellor I'Ashea L. Myles ordered the state to preserve the drugs, equipment, recordings and records from the attempt (NBC News). Pike would have been the first woman executed in Tennessee in about 200 years (CBS News).

Her lawyers, the main source on her condition, said in an Oct. 2 court filing that she was on a ventilator, and on Oct. 6 that she was conscious and speaking (WSMV).

On Oct. 8, they said she was walking with help and eating, but that memory and concentration problems remain. They have renewed their request that the governor commute her sentence (AP via PBS, ABC News).

She was discharged from the hospital in October and returned to the Debra K. Johnson Rehabilitation Center, where she is held in the infirmary (WSMV). In a statement dictated to her lawyers and released Oct. 30, she said she walked into the execution chamber “prepared to die” and has been in pain ever since (her statement).

Her lawyers have asked a federal judge to enforce a 2024 settlement over her prison conditions and end her isolation in the infirmary. The state says her medical providers decided the infirmary meets her needs and has asked the judge to deny the request (WSMV, WBIR via Yahoo).

Bench Watch BreakdownClemencyShow or hide the explanation
What it means
Clemency is mercy from a governor or president. One kind swaps a sentence for a lighter one, such as life in prison instead of death. That is called a commutation. It is not a court ruling. It is the governor's choice.
In this case
Pike's lawyers have asked Gov. Bill Lee to commute her death sentence. He has ordered an outside review of what went wrong on Sept. 30.
Why it matters
When the courts are done, the governor is often the last person who can change a death sentence.

In dissent from the Sept. 30 order, Justice Sotomayor wrote that vacating the stay cut short the Sixth Circuit's review of claims still pending in Pike's case (order).

Bench Watch BreakdownStay of executionShow or hide the explanation
What it means
A stay is a court order that says wait. It pauses an execution so a court has time to look at a claim. It does not cancel the sentence.
In this case
On Sept. 30, a federal appeals court paused Pike's execution. Hours later, the U.S. Supreme Court lifted that pause. Three justices disagreed. The state then went ahead.
Why it matters
Once a stay is lifted, the state can move forward, even while a lower court is still looking at the case.

The Supreme Court's Sept. 30 order

Timeline

  1. Tennessee asks Chancellor Myles to rescind the part of her order letting Pike's lawyers inspect, collect and test leftover pentobarbital, saying it would reveal the supplier

  2. Pike's lawyers ask a federal judge to enforce a 2024 settlement and end her isolation in the prison infirmary; the state later asks the judge to deny the request

  3. Gov. Lee names Christopher Hansen interim commissioner of the Department of Correction

  4. Davidson County Chancery Court orders the state to preserve drugs, equipment and records from the execution attempt

  5. Gov. Lee's office says former U.S. Attorney Ed Stanton will lead the review; Lee says Correction Commissioner Frank Strada will step down

  6. Gov. Bill Lee orders a third-party review late that night and pauses the state's remaining 2026 executions

  7. Execution attempt by lethal injection at Riverbend Maximum Security Institution does not cause death; witnesses dismissed at 8:53 p.m.

  8. Supreme Court vacates the Sixth Circuit's stay (No. 26A428); Justices Sotomayor, Kagan and Jackson dissent

  9. Sixth Circuit stays the execution 2-1 in In re Pike, No. 26-5864

  10. Supreme Court denies review and a stay (Nos. 26-5696, 26A414)

  11. Federal district court transfers Pike's new motion to the Sixth Circuit as a successive petition; Tennessee Supreme Court denies motion to recall its 2011 mandate

  12. Pike files petition for review and stay application in the Supreme Court

  13. Tennessee Supreme Court denies a stay

  14. Special master holds a three-day hearing on Pike's method-of-execution challenge

  15. Pike files method-of-execution challenge under Tennessee Supreme Court Rule 12(4)(E)

  16. Sixth Circuit upholds the denial of her federal habeas petition, Pike v. Gross, No. 16-5854

  17. Federal district court denies habeas petition, Pike v. Freeman, No. 1:12-cv-00035 (E.D. Tenn.)

  18. Colleen Slemmer, 19, is killed; Pike is later convicted of first-degree murder and conspiracy and sentenced to death (1996)

Primary documents

Our coverage

Key questions

What happened at Christa Pike's execution?
Tennessee attempted to execute Pike by lethal injection on Sept. 30, 2026. Witnesses said she was still breathing when they were told to leave that evening, and she did not die. The state says it followed its protocol; the governor has ordered a third-party review.
What did the Supreme Court decide in Christa Pike's case?
It denied her petition for review and a stay on Sept. 29, 2026, and on Sept. 30 lifted a Sixth Circuit stay of execution. Justices Sotomayor, Kagan and Jackson dissented from the Sept. 30 order. The Court gave no reasons.
Can Tennessee try to execute Christa Pike again?
As of Nov. 14, 2026, no new execution date has been set, and the state has not said whether it will try again. Gov. Bill Lee paused the state's remaining 2026 executions, and his office announced that former U.S. Attorney Ed Stanton would lead an outside review. Her lawyers have asked the governor to commute her sentence. Lee leaves office in January 2027; voters elected Marsha Blackburn governor on Nov. 3.
Why was Christa Pike sentenced to death?
A Tennessee jury convicted her in 1996 of first-degree murder and conspiracy in the January 1995 killing of Colleen Slemmer, 19, and imposed a death sentence that state and federal courts have upheld.

Approach the Bench · How you can take part

  1. Contact your officials

    Clemency is the governor's decision

    Only Tennessee's governor can commute a death sentence. Gov. Bill Lee has ordered an outside review of the Sept. 30 attempt. Lee leaves office in January 2027; voters elected Marsha Blackburn governor on Nov. 3, 2026. You can reach the governor's office directly.

    Contact the governor's office

  2. Contact your officials

    Death-penalty laws are written by lawmakers

    Tennessee's legislature writes the state's death-penalty laws, including how executions are carried out. Find the lawmakers who represent you.

    Find your officials

  3. Learn more

    Follow the review and the court fight

    We're tracking the governor's review and Pike's case in the Sixth Circuit. Every new filing goes in the case file.

Disagree with a ruling? Only the people in a case can appeal it. You can still be heard by contacting your officials, voting in judicial elections where judges are elected and telling us what we're missing.

See something? Tell Bench Watch at tips@bench-watch.org. A wrong ruling is a matter for appeal. You can report bias or misconduct by a judge to your state's judicial conduct office.

Watch the court record with us.

Subscribe on YouTube (opens in a new tab)

In court and in the news

Clips from the outlets that covered the case, each credited.

  • Gov. Bill Lee reacts to the failed execution

    WBIR Channel 10 · Gov. Lee speaks on Oct. 1, 2026.

  • The Supreme Court allows the execution to proceed

    WKRN News 2 · Sept. 30, 2026.

  • Pike's attorneys give an update

    WBIR Channel 10 · News conference, Oct. 7, 2026. · Includes medical detail.

  • A media witness describes the execution attempt

    WKRN News 2 · Oct. 1, 2026. · A witness describes the execution attempt in detail.